Genetic Diversity

What you need to know (based on the AQA specification)

Genetic diversity as the number of different alleles of genes in a population. Genetic diversity is a factor enabling natural selection to occur.

Genetic diversity arises from the mutations and meiosis covered in the previous topic. Here we look at what it means for populations and how natural selection acts on it.

Definition — Genetic diversity

Genetic diversity is the number of different alleles of genes in a population (a population = organisms of the same species).

It is a key factor in enabling natural selection to occur. Without it, every individual would respond identically to every selection pressure, and populations could not adapt.

What is the advantage of high genetic diversity in a population?

A population with high genetic diversity has many different alleles. It has more potential to respond to environmental change. A population with low genetic diversity is more vulnerable; if a new disease or environmental shift arrives, fewer individuals may carry a suitable allele.

Natural Selection

What you need to know (based on the AQA specification)

The principles of natural selection in the evolution of populations:

  • Random mutation can result in new alleles of a gene.
  • Many mutations are harmful but, in certain environments, the new allele of a gene might benefit its possessor, leading to increased reproductive success.
  • The advantageous allele is inherited by members of the next generation.
  • As a result, over many generations, the new allele increases in frequency in the population.

Natural selection acts on genetic diversity. It is the mechanism by which advantageous alleles increase in frequency over generations. Here’s the mechanism:

  1. A random mutation produces a new allele
  2. Environmental factors act as selection pressures that affect the survival chances in a population
  3. In certain environments, this allele is beneficial — giving the organism a better chance of survival or reproduction
  4. That individual is more likely to reproduce and pass the allele on
  5. Over many generations, the advantageous allele increases in frequency in the population

What is a selection pressure?

A selection pressure is any environmental factor that affects survival or reproductive success - disease, predation, food availability, climate. The selection pressure determines which alleles are advantageous. Change the selection pressure, and a different allele may become favoured.

Does natural selection act on the individual or the population?

Natural selection acts on individuals but the effects are seen in the population. Individuals with advantageous alleles survive and reproduce more. But the change — shifting allele frequencies — happens at the population level over many generations. An individual cannot evolve; populations do.

Types of Natural Selection

What you need to know (based on the AQA specification)

Directional selection, exemplified by antibiotic resistance in bacteria, and stabilising selection, exemplified by human birth weights.

Different selection pressures affect the type of natural selection. Two important patterns are directional and stabilising selection.

Directional Selection

Directional selection favours one extreme phenotype, shifting the population mean over generations.

Example — antibiotic resistance in bacteria:

  • A random mutation gives some bacteria resistance to an antibiotic
  • When antibiotics are present, bacteria without the mutation die; resistant bacteria survive and reproduce
  • Over generations, the resistance allele increases in frequency — the population shifts towards resistance
  • You can see how this is exploited in recombinant DNA technology in Unit 8

Common exam mistake — resistance vs immunity

Bacteria become resistant to antibiotics. They are not immune. Immunity involves the immune system responding to a specific antigen. Resistance means the bacterium has an allele that allows it to survive antibiotic exposure.

Stabilising Selection

Stabilising selection favours intermediate phenotypes and selects against both extremes. The mean stays the same, but variation narrows.

Example — human birth weight:

  • Very low birth weight: higher infant mortality
  • Very high birth weight: higher risk of complications during birth
  • Intermediate birth weight: highest survival
  • Individuals with extreme birth weights are less likely to survive and reproduce, so they are less likely to pass on their alleles — over generations, extreme birth weights decrease in frequency in the population

Adaptations

What you need to know (based on the AQA specification)

Natural selection results in species that are better adapted to their environment. These adaptations may be anatomical, physiological or behavioural.

An adaptation is a feature that increases an organism’s chances of survival and reproduction in its environment. Adaptations don’t arise because an organism needs them. A random mutation happens to be beneficial, natural selection favours it, and over many generations it spreads through the population.

Can natural selection select against certain alleles?

Yes — any allele that reduces survival or reproductive success will be selected against. Individuals carrying it are less likely to survive and reproduce, so the allele decreases in frequency over generations. For example, bacteria without antibiotic resistance die when antibiotics are present. The non-resistance allele decreases in frequency.

Three types of adaptation

  • Anatomical — structural / physical features
  • Physiological — internal processes and biochemistry
  • Behavioural — how an organism acts

Anatomical Adaptations examples

  • Large surface area of alveoli for efficient gas exchange
  • Streamlined body shape in fish for reducing drag
  • Xerophytic adaptations — e.g. sunken stomata, rolled leaves, and thick waxy cuticles in desert plants to reduce water loss

Physiological Adaptations examples

  • Fetal haemoglobin has a higher oxygen affinity than adult haemoglobin, allowing efficient oxygen transfer from mother to fetus — see haemoglobin dissociation curves
  • Desert mammals have a longer loop of Henle — this creates a steeper sodium ion gradient in the medulla, allowing more water to be reabsorbed and producing more concentrated urine — see the kidney
  • Some bacteria produce enzymes that break down antibiotics

Behavioural Adaptations examples

  • Nocturnal activity in desert animals to avoid daytime heat
  • Migration to warmer climates in winter
  • Courtship displays to attract mates

Required Practical 6 — Antimicrobial Substances

What you need to know (based on the AQA specification)

Use of aseptic techniques to investigate the effect of antimicrobial substances on microbial growth.

This practical links directly to directional selection and antibiotic resistance, the same evolutionary pressure you investigated theoretically above.

Aseptic Technique

Aseptic technique prevents contamination of the culture (by unwanted microorganisms)

Key steps:

  • Sterilise all equipment before use — autoclave glassware and agar; flame the neck of the bottle before removing bacteria
  • Work near a Bunsen flame — convection currents carry microorganisms away from the work area
  • Incubate at 25°C — not 37°C (body temperature), to reduce the risk of culturing human pathogens

Method

  1. Prepare a sterile agar plate and inoculate it evenly with a bacterial culture using a sterile spreader
  2. Soak small paper discs in different antimicrobial substances (or different concentrations of the same substance)
  3. Include a control disc soaked in distilled water (no antimicrobial)
  4. Place discs on the agar surface, evenly spaced
  5. Seal, invert, and incubate at 25°C for 24–48 hours
  6. Measure the diameter (or calculate the area) of the inhibition zone around each disc

Interpreting Results

  • Inhibition zone — the clear area around a disc where bacteria have not grown
  • Larger zone = more effective antimicrobial substance
  • No zone = bacteria are resistant (or the substance has no effect)
  • Area of inhibition zone = π r²

Zone of inhibition diagram

Look at the diagram above. Which antibiotic is most effective? Which show no effect?

Antibiotic 2 is most effective — it has the largest zone of inhibition. Antibiotics 1 and 6 have no zone of inhibition, meaning these bacteria are resistant to them (or they have no antimicrobial effect on this species).

What does a large inhibition zone tell you about the antimicrobial substance?

It is more effective at inhibiting bacterial growth. The larger the zone, the greater the effect on this bacterial species. Note: inhibition zones from different experiments or different bacteria cannot be directly compared.

Why is a control disc (soaked in distilled water) included?

To confirm that any inhibition zone is caused by the antimicrobial substance, not the disc itself. It provides a baseline for comparison. Without it, you cannot be sure the disc material has no effect.

Exam Questions

Natural selection for disease resistance

In Africa today, most of the human population are resistant to malaria caused by P. vivax. Use your knowledge of natural selection to explain why this resistance is so common in Africa.

(4 marks)
Hint

Apply natural selection to this specific context. What produces the initial variation? What is the selection pressure? What happens to individuals with and without the resistance allele? What happens to allele frequency over time?

Mark Scheme
  1. Mutation produced a (resistance) allele (1 mark)
  2. Those with the allele / resistance less likely to get malaria / survive malaria (1 mark)
  3. (So more likely to) reproduce and pass on the allele (1 mark)
  4. (Over generations) allele frequency increases (1 mark)
Comments from mark scheme
  • Reject ‘gene’ for ‘allele’ (once only)
  • Reject ‘mutation caused by infection / exposure to P. vivax’
  • Accept converse: ‘people lacking the allele die from malaria’
  • Accept description of increasing frequency: ‘higher proportion’, ‘more common’
  • Reject ‘increase in number of allele’
Tips from examiner reports
  • Apply natural selection to the specific context — don’t just write generic stock phrases
  • A mutation produces a new allele — say ‘allele’ not ‘gene’ when discussing inheritance
  • Mention what the selection pressure is (malaria) and how resistance provides a survival advantage
  • The sequence: mutation → new allele → survival advantage → increased reproduction → allele frequency increases
Required Practical 6

Give two precautions a student should take when using aseptic technique to culture bacteria. Give a reason for each precaution.

(2 marks)
Hint

Think about what could go wrong without each precaution: contamination of the culture, or risk to the experimenter.

Mark Scheme
  1. Work near a Bunsen flame — convection currents carry microorganisms away, preventing contamination (1 mark)
  2. Incubate at 25°C not 37°C — reduces risk of culturing human pathogens (1 mark)
  3. Do not breathe over open plates — prevents contamination from exhaled microorganisms (1 mark)
  4. Sterilise equipment (autoclave / flame loop) — kills any microorganisms on equipment before use (1 mark)

(Any 2 precaution + reason pairs for 2 marks)

Comments from mark scheme
  • Must give both the precaution AND the reason for each mark
  • Accept any valid aseptic precaution with a correct justification
Tips from examiner reports
  • Students often state the precaution but forget the reason — both are required for each mark
  • “Wear gloves” alone is insufficient — must link to a reason (prevents contamination / skin flora)
Required Practical 6

A student tested three antimicrobial substances (A, B, C) against a bacterial species. The diameters of the inhibition zones were: A = 12 mm, B = 0 mm, C = 20 mm. What conclusions can the student draw from these results?

(3 marks)
Hint

Interpret each result separately. What does a large zone mean? What does zero mean? Can you rank effectiveness?

Mark Scheme
  1. Substance C is the most effective antimicrobial — largest inhibition zone (1 mark)
  2. Substance A inhibits bacterial growth / has some antimicrobial effect (1 mark)
  3. Substance B has no effect on this bacterial species / the bacteria are resistant to B (1 mark)
Comments from mark scheme
  • Accept “inhibits bacterial growth” or “prevents bacterial growth” — do not require “kills”
  • For substance B: accept “no inhibition zone” as evidence of no effect / resistance
Tips from examiner reports
  • Do not say “kills bacteria” when interpreting inhibition zones — bacteria may be inhibited, not killed
  • A larger inhibition zone means greater effectiveness — but only for the same bacterium; results cannot be compared across different species
Required Practical 6

Explain why a control disc soaked in distilled water should be included in the investigation.

(2 marks)
Hint

What is the purpose of a control in any experiment?

Mark Scheme
  1. To confirm any inhibition zone is caused by the antimicrobial substance and not the disc itself (1 mark)
  2. Allows a valid comparison / acts as a baseline (1 mark)
Comments from mark scheme
  • Accept “to show the disc alone has no effect on bacterial growth”
  • Reject “to make it a fair test” alone — must be more specific
Tips from examiner reports
  • Students often say “to make it fair” without explaining what the control shows — be specific about what is being controlled for